When cutting different materials, you have a wide variety of potential choices to make in what method you want to cut with. The two most common methods include waterjet cutting and using a plasma cutter. These two methods each have different benefits when you are debating what to choose to cut the desired material.
The differences between waterjet cutting and using a plasma cutter are that waterjet cutters can be:
- More accurate
- Last longer
- Have no heat-related effects
- Can cut a wider variety of materials
- Can cut layers and indents
- More environmentally friendly
While plasma cutting’s benefits over waterjet cutting are that plasma cutting can be:
- Less noisy
- Is able to cut the major metals used in industries
There are many factors in determining whether you want to use a waterjet machine or a plasma cutter table. You will need to identify your priority values so you can choose the best plasma cutter or the best waterjet cutter for your individual needs. This article will explore those factors and assist you in choosing which cutter to use based on your situation.
The Differences Between Waterjet and Plasma Cutting
When determining which type of cutter to utilize, you must understand what areas each of these cutters excel in and what areas they are lackluster compared to their counterpart.
The following categories will detail the differences between plasma cutting and waterjet cutting in many different circumstances. These are the categories that cover almost all the things one would need to think about when determining what method of cutting you need to use. They are ranked in a mindful way, in an attempt to mimic the reasoning you would use when considering which cutting system you want.
This article will be focused on non-industrial size cutters, which end up costing $500,000 and up just for the machine. We will focus on cutters that are:
- Do-it-yourself cutting
- For your small business
…since most industrial cutters are quite expensive and out of the price range of most people and companies.
Related Reading: Differences between Plasma Cutter and Oxy-acetylene Torch Cutter
First and foremost is the price. Price is the most important thing to consider when you are choosing whether to buy a plasma cutter or a waterjet cutting machine. If you find the perfect machine that checks all the parameters you need, and it is out of your price range, all that time you spent researching is wasted.
The price must always be at the forefront of your mind when looking at the two types of machines.
The average price of your “garage-type” plasma cutter will range from $1,000 for hand-held machines to $50,000 for machines that are programmable. The higher-end price range is geared more towards small businesses that regularly need plasma cutting done.
Plasma cutters come in either hand-held apparatuses or plasma cutting tables, which are the ones that are programmable to cut out specific designs. The tables start out at around $15,000 for the cheapest and run upwards of $50,000 plus.
Waterjets are much more expensive when compared to plasma cutters because waterjet cutters need an Ultra High Pressure Intensifier pump, which accounts for the vast majority of the price bump.
The cheapest water cutting desktops come in at around $10,000, which are the most basic platforms and are able to cut thin materials in simple patterns. More complex machines that are able to cut thicker materials will end up costing $100,000 and up. These expensive machines typically have a free jet head that allows them to cut diagonally and at many angles to get the product you need.
Overall, there is a very wide range of prices for both of the systems. But, getting an idea for the price range of machines is the first step anyone must take when determining to buy either a waterjet cutter or a plasma cutter machine.
Range of Cuttable Materials
After you have gotten an idea of the price range that you can afford for each machine, you need to make sure that the machine you want can cut the materials you will be working with. In this category, waterjet cutters are undoubtedly the superior choice.
Knowing what material each machine can cut is essential is choosing what machine to buy. There is no point in buying the machine and finding out that your machine cannot cut the material you need to cut.
Waterjet cutters can cut almost any material on earth. Common materials that are cut include:
Yes, it can cut literally almost any material on the planet! This makes it extremely flexible when you install one in your garage or shop. You can use the machine to make precision cuts on almost anything imaginable, which makes the machine a very useful product to have around.
Most people turn to this plus of the waterjet systems when determining what to buy since it offers a huge benefit compared to plasma cutting technology.
Plasma cutters can only cut conductive metals, which severely limits its ability compared to a water cutting system. Conductive metals still cover the majority of materials you will work with in machining and cutting, but when you need something cut that is not a conductive metal, you are out of luck. Conductive metals include:
- Stainless steel
The reason plasma cutters can only cut conductive metals lies in the way that they make the cuts. Plasma uses electrons that bind to a gas to create the plasma arc. The electrons have to move to the metal to create the heat that makes the plasma be able to cut. It is not so much as a cut, but more of a targeted melting of that particular part of the metal. The electrons need a positive charge metal in order to make the jump from the arc to the metal that makes the cut.
Fast Extreme Water Jet Cutter Machine Working >> Check out the video below
Complexity of Cuts
When you consider what type of machine to buy, you need to keep in mind the complexity of the cut that you will need to make for your specific desire. You may need cuts that are:
- At an angle
- Not full through cuts
- Have a smooth cut edge
When considering these things, waterjet cutting again proves to be superior to the plasma cutting method. Waterjet cutting gives the user more flexibility overall than what plasma cutting allows.
Waterjet cutting machines give the user unmatched customization and flexibility when cutting materials that are not present in any other form of industrial cutting. Waterjet cutting allows the user to be able to cut complex shapes that can be of any design.
The more complex waterjet cutting machines are able to choose what pressure to use to precisely cut indents in your metal or not cut all the way through your material, making it a highly sought after machine.
When compared to plasma cutting machines, waterjet machines blow them out of the water in their ability to perform complex cuts. Plasma machines are again limited by their way they cut the conductive metals.
Since plasma cutting machines essentially melt the material they are cutting, it is virtually impossible to not cut all the way through the material you are cutting and make the perfect desired design.
However, this aspect of plasma cutting can perfectly fit the type of cutting some people may be doing, and, for the low price, it can draw people to choose plasma cutting over waterjet cutting. These people do not need to cut extremely complex designs but need relatively simpler cuts.
The simplicity of the cut for the low price draws many people to choose the plasma cutter over the waterjet cutters simply because they want a cheap machine that will get the job done.
When you are cutting your materials, you want to be sure that the machine is cutting at the correct parameters, or your piece will be wasted. Most machines already are programmed to account for the amount of material their cutting stream will take off when they begin to cut, which helps tremendously with the accuracy of the cuts.
However, even with the advanced computer software, waterjet cutting again performs better than the process of plasma cutting.
A waterjet system, on average, has a cut accuracy of +/- 0.005 of an inch. Waterjet cutting machines come with a kerf width or width of the material that the stream will take completely out of the material, at 0.035 of an inch. The accuracy of waterjet cutting is unmatched in the cutting industry.
This makes waterjet cutters the preferred method in shaping and manufacturing small components of many finished goods such as:
- Machine parts
- And many more small parts
When compared to plasma cutting machines, waterjet cutters are up to four times more accurate than the plasma cutting machines. Plasma machines have an accuracy, on average, of +/-0.020 of an inch and a kerf size that is roughly four times that of a waterjet kerf at 0.150 of an inch.
Again, the source of this negative attribute comes from the way plasma cutters cut. Plasma cutters also have another negative attribute that comes with the heat generated by the cutting process. Plasma cutting can potentially heat warp thicker metals that you cut. When the metal becomes warped, it is essentially useless and a wasted piece.
Plasma cutting machines again come up short compared to their waterjet cutting counterparts, but one cannot forget the cost difference of the machines. It is because they are not as accurate, flexible, and lack the ability to cut complex cuts that waterjet machines can make, plasma cutting machines are much cheaper.
When you buy your cutter, you would want to know how long the parts of the cutter last before they have to be replaced, which can lead to a higher cost to operate. There is no point in buying a cutter that is super cheap, but you end up having to replace expensive parts on it quite often. This is another vital question you must be asking yourself when considering whether to buy a waterjet cutting machine or a plasma cutting machine.
Here, we again have a clear winner, the waterjet cutter. The waterjet cutter, because it does not generate nearly as much heat as a plasma cutter, lasts significantly longer than any plasma cutter, by a massive margin. Waterjet cutting machines also do not have nearly as many moving parts compared to a plasma cutting machine, which accounts for the vast difference in the lifespan of parts.
Waterjet cutting machines can last between 500 hours to upwards of 2,000 hours of work before parts begin to need to be replaced. This is solely due to the two factors mentioned above; lack of heat generation and very little moving parts. You can further this lifespan by buying a waterjet cutter that is made to be inserted into a tank of water to further reduce the amount of heat produced when cutting.
The source of this difference in longevity again comes from the plasma cutter’s process by which it cuts metal. Plasma cutting machines use intense heat, 40,000 degrees Fahrenheit, to melt the metal that they cut.
To generate this immense amount of heat, there are a lot of moving parts that are inside all plasma cutting machines that get up to very high temperatures and can even begin to melt. The heat is the main reason why plasma cutters have such a short lifespan.
The range of the lifespan of plasma cutting machines can be extremely varied because it relies on what type of work you are doing with the cutter itself. If you are cutting:
- A thicker metal
- For long periods of time
- Certain types of metal
All of these determine the lifespan of your plasma cutting nozzle, which will be the main thing that needs replacing on your machine. If you have a greater value of the first three factors on the list, then the lifespan of the plasma cutter is reduced.
Plasma cutting steel >> Check the video below
Cut speed is essential in determining what type of cutter you need. The speed at which you will cut determines how many items you can cut or how productive you can be. When you cut faster, you save time, and, as we all know, time is money.
In this category, plasma cutting machines clearly outpace their waterjet cutting counterparts. Aspects of the material that directly impact the speed at which you are able to cut for both systems are:
- Thickness of material
- Desired accuracy
- Complexity of cut
- And the type of material
Overall, plasma cutting machines can cut at a blistering rate of 60 to 200 inches per minute. This may sound slow, but in the cutting industry, it is extremely fast. Again, the variability comes from the four variables aforementioned.
If you have a thicker metal, it will take longer to cut with any type of cutter. If you want greater accuracy, you will need to cut at a slower rate. If you want to cut a more complex shape or design, you will need more time to cut this design. Also, there will be a great variance in cut time if you want to cut metal vs. Styrofoam for a waterjet cutter, you will find it much quicker to cut the softer material than the metal.
Waterjet cutters cut at an extremely slow rate, at least four times slower, at a rate between 15 inches per minute down to a fraction of an inch per minute. This makes plasma cutting machines much more efficient in cutting when you look at saving time for each cut. You are able to perform more cuts, in a quicker amount of time, at an overall cheaper cost using a plasma cutter compared to a waterjet cutter.
Now that we have gotten through most of what comes to mind when you are thinking about purchasing a cutting machine, you also have to think about the environmental impact that the cutter that you choose will have.
Waterjet cutters are the clear victors in this regard. Waterjet cutting machines have very little environmental impact when they cut and during operation. The water itself is easily able to be recycled and put down a drain. In regard to the material itself, the kerf that the waterjet has allows you to save more material than the plasma cutting machines.
Where waterjet cutters fall behind plasma cutting machines is that waterjet cutting machines produce a lot of noise pollution. They are extremely loud. As more studies come out saying that noise pollution is detrimental to the environment and to the health of people, one must also think about the noise produced by the machines they are operating.
The noise level can be greatly reduced by putting the waterjet cutter into a tank of water to operate in.
Plasma cutting machines produce a toxic gas when they cut the metal. The toxic gas is very acidic and has many hazardous materials that are a by-product of the cutting process. Studies have been conducted to show the continuous inhaling of this toxic smoke does damage the lungs of the user.
When deciding what type of machine you want to use, you must consider the categories outlined in the article. Price, above all, is most important, as it is when deciding to purchase any expensive item.
When looking at a plasma cutting machine, you should choose one if you want a:
- Cheaper machine
- Not performing complex cuts
- Only cutting conductive metals
- Faster cut speeds
You should choose a waterjet cutting machine when you:
- Want a more accurate cut
- Performing complex cuts
- Want a longer-lasting machine
- Has a lesser environmental impact